Should We Be Fly Fishers of Men? šŸŽ£ 

thinking messaging
Braden East

A good friend of mine who used to be a youth pastor just opened up the first brick-and-mortar location for his fly fishing business.

It got me thinking about how Jesus made his disciples to be fishers of men (Matthew 4), which, in those days, called to mind an image of casting nets. But what about using a lure? Is it appropriate to ā€œbaitā€ people toward the gospel by making our visuals flashier and our colors brighter in the name of more effective man-fishing?

My conclusion is no. Well, usually no. Jesus’ model of evangelism and ministry was markedly NOT seeker-sensitive. If your goal with church branding is to baptize marketing trends and tactics, you’ll be surprised at how few people stick around and put down roots in your congregation.

What you win them with is what you win them to.

That’s why a brand based on vision and congregational identity can last for decades, while a brand based on cultural relevance and eye candy feels like a ā€œbait and switch.ā€

For my friend, tying flies started as a hobby on the side. He would source exotic materials and study the quirks of different fish species to create unique flies that looked more fine art than fishing gear. These things were beautiful.

It’s not wrong to build beautiful buildings, design beautiful logos, or lean into an aesthetic. Those are good things, and they can help to attract people to a church.

But those people should be there for what the brand represents, not the brand itself.

A well-crafted and positioned brand is a beautiful, visual manifestation of your church’s identity and mission, not a flashy lure.


Related to ā€œthinkingā€
Two Strategies to Blast Through Creative Block
Published on:
Every day around mid-morning, I take a bathroom break and that’s when I write these posts - gross I know, but it’s the perfect amount of time and I have no distractions (now you won’t be able to get that image out of your mind, so you’re welcome). Context aside, when I’m motivated and inspired it’s easy, but today I had some serious creative block of the ā€œstare vacantly at a blank page and start the same sentence five times overā€ variety. I have a hunch this doesn’t just happen to creatives. Most of my readers are church leaders, I’ll wager that you probably experience that wall too. If so, maybe you can benefit from the two strategies I use to overcome creative block. 1. Short term strategy Exercise is my immediate strategy for overcoming it in the short term. I’ll go home after work, grab my dumbbells, and start lifting. Something about an intense workout stimulates my creativity and writing energy. However, that only works on that day, and if I can’t get a workout in, I’m in trouble. 2. Long term strategy My long term strategy to overcome creative block is to write daily. I used to think I didn’t have time for something recreational like writing, much less every day. But I realized that as long as I put it on the other side of something I enjoy more (chess puzzles), I could force myself to take 5-15 minutes and crank out a thought. Writing became a habit I was cultivating. Something you practice with regularity and discipline becomes easier and easier, and those creative block moments get fewer and farther between. Even when it takes a bit longer to get rolling, the groove is greased and the engine is still warm from yesterday. If there’s something you know you should be doing (maybe writing, maybe calling to check in on members, maybe something else) make it a small part of your daily routine and see how much you start feeling empowered when those ā€œblockā€ moments hit.
Yes, Form = Function
Published on:
We often think of form and function as a dichotomy. Sacrificing beauty for efficiency is putting function over form. Making something sleek and attractive at the cost of performance is putting form over function. Here’s my hot take: The form-function dichotomy is wrong. Form and function are two sides of the same coin. The name of the coin is elegance, or more simply ā€œgoodness.ā€ And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good. — Genesis 1:31a We don’t assess beauty in a vacuum. If a thing doesn’t accomplish its purpose, can it be beautiful? The Roman aqueducts were built with masterful craftsmanship and still stand to this day, 2000 years later. They transported millions of gallons of water over a hundred miles, making them extremely functional. But would they be beautiful if they didn’t work? If a thing’s only purpose is to be beautiful, does it matter if it can do anything else?
Why the Grace Font and the Dyslexia Friendly Bible is Brilliant
Published on:
A few months ago, Crossway released The Dyslexia-Friendly Bible, featuring a new font they called ā€œGrace.ā€ The design team took a data-driven approach, carefully studying and testing what tiny details makes a font more accessible for dyslexic readers. This Bible also featured special design touches to make the reading experience more approachable, and less fatiguing. The team working on the design used existing studies, focus groups, and user testing to optimize things like paragraph spacing and line height (and other technical specs we designers are thinking about all the time). The end result was a beautiful product that is already changing the way thousands read and access God’s Word. This brings me the same joy as when the Scriptures are translated into a new language. Praise God! It’s also a good reminder that intentional design can make your localized vision and message accessible to a previously ā€œunreachedā€ people group. Are you studying what prevents your congregation and community from "getting" it?
Does Your Visual Identity Suit You?
Published on:
If you have a good sense of fashion or a job that requires professional attire, you may have at one point gotten a custom-fitted suit. I’ve done this myself, and it felt great to have a jacket and pants that had been tweaked to fit my measurements. But the next level up is something I’ve never done, and that’s getting a custom-tailored suit made from scratch, with full customization of every detail. Unless you’re lucky and have a very specific body-type and build, you probably won’t find an existing garment that fits you as well as a bespoke suit would. I had a friend who got this done right after college, and I remember thinking, ā€œBoy, I buy my shirts at TJ-Maxx, but he’s a real adult.ā€ Here’s the application: Getting a custom-tailored suit signals personal maturity. In a similar way, getting a custom-tailored visual identity signals organizational maturity. For a visual identity to be custom-tailored means each part is carefully crafted to fit your organization. The logo is designed to represent your vision. The wordmark is tweaked and hand-picked to evoke a particular feeling. The colors are harmonized to stand out in your local context. Getting a bespoke visual identity signals organizational maturity. Bonus: If you have a custom-tailored suit with a very specific look, you probably don’t have to worry about theft - It won’t fit just anyone who tries it on.
Related to ā€œmessagingā€
What is a Verbal Identity? And Why it Matters for Churches (Pt. 2 Tone of Voice)
Published on:
In the last post, I looked at how vocabulary contributes to a cohesive verbal identity, and can be useful for a church trying to elevate their communications. Today, we’re on to the second part of a verbal identity: tone of voice. Now with AI tools, tone of voice guidelines are even more incredibly useful. Just ask this pastor I worked with on a recent rebrand. He was writing content for a connect card they could use to gather information from visitors, and he was blown away by how helpful it was to have a brand tone of voice. ā€œBro, ChatGPT is crazy cool… I put in the tone description from our brand guidelines, and it gave me all kinds of good options!ā€ Here’s the tone description he was talking about: ā€œOur tone is bold yet humble—serious about truth, passionate about people, and always inviting others into something real. We speak with clarity, conviction, and warmth, aiming to reflect both the reverence of our faith and the relational heart of our church.ā€ If you saw a social media post with exclamation points, emoji’s and emotional word choice, you would probably expect a passionate, informal, and loud worship service on Sunday morning. Now, what if you showed up to that church and found a conservative Presbyterian church with organ-led hymns and a serious vibe. Would you be confused? Inconsistent writing style can even leave visitors with a subtle feeling of being confused or tricked, rather than edified. In the end, looking the part is critically important, but your visuals are ultimately just the vehicle for what can only be communicated through written (or spoken) words.
What is a Verbal Identity? And Why it Matters for Churches (Pt. 1 Vocabulary)
Published on:
In a church rebrand project, I tend to focus mainly on designing the congregation’s visual identity. However, there’s a key part of branding that doesn’t always get as much attention, which I’ve started including in the church brand guides I create. That piece is a verbal identity. A consistent writing style is crucial in church communications, and I’m breaking it down into its two fundamental parts today. If the content of your bulletin reads dramatically different from the content of your website, which reads different from your social media, then your overall message won’t land with the same impact. So, let’s look at the two key facets of a verbal identity: vocabulary and tone of voice. Brand Vocabulary The words you choose to use in official church creative work and communication should be a reflection of who you are speaking to, and how you want them to view you. Here’s an example of brand vocabulary guidelines: ā€œIn our church communications, we occasionally use words like ā€˜y’all’ and ā€˜fixin’ to identify with our main demographic of ranchers and homesteaders here in rural Oklahoma. These words should not be overused in a cliche way, but should be sprinkled in to add warmth and familiarity to our written copy.ā€ In the next post, I’ll look at the other facet of a verbal identity: tone of voice.
Branded Words
Published on:
For those of us that read books, we quickly find a favorite author who we can’t put down. I’m curious how well you really know yours. If I put five excerpts by different authors in front of you, could you tell which one was written by your favorite author? What would give it away? I’m a fan of sci-fi, and my favorite author is currently Blake Crouch. He writes with a unique combination of vivid detail and grungy vocabulary. I like to think I could absolutely tell when a book is written by him. This identifying power of the words we choose and the tone we use is one of the key elements in branding. When a brand is polished, refined, and bolstered, it would be a mistake to leave out defining the word choice and tone of voice that brand speaks with. Tend your whole brand, and choose a tone of voice that will reinforce your message.
The Medium is the Message
Published on:
Marshall McLuhan was a Canadian communication theorist who coined the phrase, ā€œThe medium is the message.ā€ In other words: how you choose to say something changes what your audience walks away with. McLuhan’s point was that each medium doesn’t just deliver your message - it shapes it and sends unspoken signals like: The value you place on the relationship How urgent or serious something is How you want to be perceived Let’s look at an example. Sending a text message says, ā€œI want to be quick and efficient.ā€ A phone call says, ā€œThis is personal.ā€ The words exchanged can be the same, but the vibe of that medium changes what message actually gets received. Effective branding is effective communication, so it’s important to understand this idea! Here are a few church-specific examples: Animated sermon graphics say, ā€œWe care about looking fresh and young.ā€ A church-wide email newsletter says, ā€œWe expect our members to stay informed.ā€ Hand-written note cards from a pastor or staff member say, ā€œYou are known and cared for.ā€ You have core ideas and feelings about your church that you want your congregation and community to ā€œget.ā€ The medium can either supercharge or neutralize the power of those ideas. If they’re not getting it, you might want to find a different way of presenting it.
← Back to all posts
Almost there!

Enter your email below to get the weekly Tend Your Brand digest.